responsiveslider_lol_02 The Language of Light DVD - More
MeetJoe_02 Meet Joe McNally - More
inthebag What’s in the Bag? - More

A Wonderful Day In New York City

Mar 13

In Uncategorized at 10:44pm

Now I know to some folks, “wonderful day” and “New York City” don’t belong in the same sentence. But I have always loved the city, lived there for 16 years (not anymore), and have fond memories of the energy, the lights, Central Park, first runs of movies, and yes, even the muck, the squalor and the noise.

FGZ Grand Central StationAfter 9/11, I shot a project on the world’s only Giant Polaroid camera that was known as Faces of Ground Zero. (Maybe in a future blog, I’ll talk a bit about it, and this singular beast of a camera–interior chamber of the camera is the size of a one car garage, for starters, and in 90 seconds you peel the backing off a 4’x9′ life size image.)


One of the gifts doing the project gave me is the lasting emotional relationships I have with people who came before the camera. One of those is with Archbishop Demetrios, the spiritual leader of the Greek Orthodox Church in North America. He graciously agreed to see me yesterday to present him with a copy of The Moment It Clicks, which has a photo of him in it.

The photo in question came from the assignment I received from the church to make the Archbishop’s official portrait. What an honor of an assignment! I got a chance to make a picture that will last in the annals of the Greek church for all time, way past the time they pry my D17xs from my cold dead fingers. (That’s ambitious, eh?)

Archbishop Demetrios Archbishop Demetrios

We sat and talked for about a half hour. He is one of the most decent people I have ever met. He radiates forgiveness, warmth and a love of humanity in all it’s shapes and forms. I took a deep breath when I got out of the building and onto 79th St. Proximity to such goodness lightens anyone’s mind and heart, even a prone-to-be-cynical 30 year career photog. The irony of feeling such a blast of clear air in my head and my heart was that the Greek Archdiocese offices are directly across the street from former Governor Spitzer’s residence. The news trucks were still there, and you could smell the smolder of something that had gone terribly wrong.

Mom's Hands with DollThen I headed west, across the park and delivered a book to my mentor and editor, John Loengard. John was a staff photographer at LIFE who become the magazine’s DOP for a long time. We sat and talked pictures for about an hour and a half, and it was just remarkable. He remains one of the truly smart and perceptive picture people walking around. His book, Pictures Under Discussion, is a must read for anyone involved in photography. I took a class from John called “Editorial Concepts in Photography” at the ICP in 1977. 30 years ago! I was a copyboy at the New York Daily News. He gave us an assignment on dolls. This was a great assignment, and one of those beginning points. I made this photo of my mother’s hands with an Alexander doll. I have photographed hands ever since.

Ivan BankoffFor class, I also started photographing a gentleman named Ivan Bankoff who would pluck his ukulele outside of the tonier shops on 5th Avenue, and lived in my building. (Should give you an idea of what a high rent place that was.) He would occasionally pull in a fiver from a well heeled passerby, and pull it out of his hat and wink as he pocketed it. He would regale me with tales of his days in vaudeville, a showman to his core.

John flipped through Clicks like it was a flip book, and then paused and looked at me and said, “You know I’m a fast looker, right Joe?” I smiled and reminded him of the first time I brought a carousel of pictures to him at LIFE around 1980. They were splashy and full of color, but utterly devoid of content. He never took his finger off the advance button except to pause and say, “You know I’m a fast looker, right Joe?” He also noted very pointedly that my controlled work, the work with strobe, had more “energy” than the more reportage pics in the tray. A harbinger of a career to come.

Still the same John, and by that I mean as quick witted and sensitive to nuance and detail as ever. After his review, he looked over and said he thought the book was terrific. Then he went on to say that the Steve Martin picture was “tilted” a bit, in a way LIFE had not done, and he liked it better in the book. Also, he was smiling at me but his eyes narrowed in disapproval as he noted, “You cropped Bernstein.” And he held up the gold man on the roof, and asked if I had lost the original. True enough, the repro of that picture is not as good as it could be.

This all happened in just a couple of minutes. We went on to talk of the field, and what photographers do now to survive, and he said, “This book is not your best work.” I readily agreed. It was not meant to be that. Some of the pictures I chose were failures on certain levels, or addressed field problems or mistakes. He gave, as always, good advice. He counseled me to think about the book. The book. The one I leave behind. “It may take you 5 years to do, Joe. You should think about it now.”

dscn1044.jpg Rats–all the good titles are taken.

We rambled, and bitched in genteel fashion, which is what happens when two photographers sit down for any length of time. His voice has always been clear and consistent, and I have heard it on location often, sometimes in the back, but very often the front of my head. It was good to hear it again.

Pablo says:

on March 13, 2008 at 11:23 pm

Thanks for the glimpses of all these decent folk you’ve met during a 30 year photog career. About the time I’m thinking Joe’s head might pop, you share (rather, it oozes out) a humane part of yourself that I find surprising.
Even as a non-drinker, I’d like to go have a beer w/ you & talk photos. ha!

Harry says:

on March 14, 2008 at 12:02 am


As an old (and by that I mean former) news shooter, don’t you miss some of those “stake-outs” like the one in front of Spitzer’s apartment? Isn’t that where you really got some of your best experience as a photog? We’d love to hear some street stories from back in the day and how that kind of deadline pressure in a news enviorment made better at what you do now. BTW, your book is a treasure and could easily become a text book for photojournalists. Congratulations.

Rick says:

on March 14, 2008 at 12:31 am

Great story and memories. I would love to see Faces of Ground Zero in person, that is amazing work. By the way, I have “Moment” and loved it – great book, made me laugh several times – thanks for that!

Now, I can’t wait 5-years for the next book…so get cracking.

Gregg Zivney says:

on March 14, 2008 at 6:46 am

“… and he said, “This book is not your best work.”
For that fraction of a second, that time between what he said and what he meant, how did you feel?

Malinda Hartong says:

on March 14, 2008 at 7:50 am


Mark K. says:

on March 14, 2008 at 8:31 am

You tell a story as well with words as you do with your photos. The meeting with the Archbishop sounds amazing and the sit-down with John equally entralling.

And I hope you do blog about the 9/11 Polaroid project. My wife and I still talk about attending the opening in New York. A special night for you and for everyone there to be sure.

Billy Mitchell says:

on March 14, 2008 at 9:03 am

Didn’t I just say after your last blog that you would have to write another book?

…Maybe “How I’m going to do it”?

Ken Wilcox says:

on March 14, 2008 at 4:48 pm

Dale Moreau says:

on March 14, 2008 at 4:58 pm

Hi Joe,

Thanks for the blog and the book.
I had the great pleasure of hearing you and a collective rabble of noteworthy shooters at photoshop world in Boston last year, best photo event I’ve ever attended. Your presentation and banter with Versace, Maisel, Caponigro, Peterson and the others was great.
I am also greatly impressed with your movie selection. as another 56 year old, it is always nice to see the Holy Grail and Young Frankenstein referenced as they should be. ( I only own three movies, those are two of them),
Sorry I missed your workshop in Maine last year. I’ll keep my eye out.


Billy Mitchell says:

on March 14, 2008 at 10:32 pm

Joe, Is Polariod going to continue to make the film for the big Polariod camera?

Joey Daoud says:

on March 23, 2008 at 9:22 pm

NYC Ticket says:

on October 18, 2008 at 4:47 pm

I am humbled that you were able to share your experience with Archbishop Demetrios with all of us. I have met him a few years ago when he was a guest in Saddle Brook, New Jersey at Saint Athanasios. He radiated not only a sense of peace, but gave one the feeling that he/she would be able to reveal their inner workings with him without holding anything back. In my humble opinion, he is one of the most selfless people I have ever encountered. That one visit alone put me in a sense of utter peace within my faith. Mind you, I have drifted from my faith for many years, but I remember my mother calling me up asking that I go with her this one week because my dad was out of town with my brother’s family (and my mother wasn’t able to take off from her job @ the hospital). Needless to say, I still think to this day that she did that on purpose. Since then I only missed 3 weeks of services. I still may not be the most devout church-goer, but the fact that my own family didn’t stray away when I asked them to accompany me to the local G.O. church the following week only strengthed mine. I thank you (even though his holiness was only part of your blog) for putting this up. It means everything to me.

Leave a Reply